SetLength warnings - request

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
1 message Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view

SetLength warnings - request




even if there's closed issue I would like to ask if it can be reconsidered.


The subject is that SetLength now gives warning: Variable "dynamic array" of a managed type does not seem to be initialized

in 3.3.1 and 3.1.1 while it doesn't give any warning in stable 3.0.4


As a solution is recommended do declaration: var arr: array of widechar = ();

But it means that initialization is in fact done twice. See assembler of following code:


procedure TForm1.Button1Click(Sender: TObject);

var DA: array of widechar = ();


  SetLength(DA, 10);




unit1.pas:30                              var DA: array of widechar = ();

00000000004696C9 488d1538536600           lea    0x665338(%rip),%rdx        # 0xacea08 <RTTI_$UNIT1_$$_def00000138>

00000000004696D0 488b3529536600           mov    0x665329(%rip),%rsi        # 0xacea00 <TC_$UNIT1$_$TFORM1_$_BUTTON1CLICK$TOBJECT_$$_defaultDA>

00000000004696D7 4889e7                   mov    %rsp,%rdi

00000000004696DA e8d199fcff               callq  0x4330b0 <fpc_dynarray_assign>

unit1.pas:32                              SetLength(DA, 10);

00000000004696DF 48c74424680a000000       movq   $0xa,0x68(%rsp)

00000000004696E8 488d3519536600           lea    0x665319(%rip),%rsi        # 0xacea08 <RTTI_$UNIT1_$$_def00000138>

00000000004696EF 488d4c2468               lea    0x68(%rsp),%rcx

00000000004696F4 4889e7                   mov    %rsp,%rdi

00000000004696F7 ba01000000               mov    $0x1,%edx

00000000004696FC e8df99fcff               callq  0x4330e0 <fpc_dynarray_setlength>

unit1.pas:33                              writeln(DA[0]);

To avoid warning we now need four extra instructions incl. call to fpc_array_assign, which is obviously redundant.
As an explanation is written: "Setlength uses a var parameter. This is no different from other cases of var parameter usage."
I disaggre here, because SetLength is not an usual procedure, it is fundamental part of compiler. Therefore it deserves some exception.
That's why I ask for reconsidering and make it behave like in 3.0.4 or change declaration from "var" to "out" as it is done in getmem().
Thanks, Vojtěch.

fpc-pascal maillist  -  [hidden email]